A secret document dating back to talks between senior officials from the United States, the United Kingdom, France and the Federal Republic of Germany (FRG) in Bonn on 6 March 1991, showed that the West and the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation "NATO" did not abide by its promises not to expand to the east, even by "one centimetre".The German newspaper, "Spiegel", said that the secret document, recovered from the British National Archives, provides evidence that Western countries have agreed to reject the membership of Eastern European countries in the alliance, which means that Russia's current grievance about NATO's expansion to the east is justified.
Is it true?
Falseaccording to EUvsDisinfo
EUvsDisinfo checked this claim on 26 February 2022.
“disinformation”
Why it is false, according to EUvsDisinfo
- NATO Secretary-General Stoltenberg told Der Spiegel that there was never such a promise or behind-the-scenes deal on NATO's eastward expansion.
- Declassified White House transcripts show that in 1997 Bill Clinton consistently refused Boris Yeltsin's offer of a gentlemen's agreement that no former Soviet Republics would enter NATO.
Summarised by Factiz from the EUvsDisinfo disproof (CC BY 4.0). Read the disproof
In a sample, we checked 292 points by hand; 3 did not fully match the source. Report an error
Around this claim
- First seen
- 26 February 2022, addiyar.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force) · and 15 more
Where it turned up
- Seen at addiyar.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at almahjar.net, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at amad, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at amadpress.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at arabic.sputniknews.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at boyemen.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at bwabtk.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at cratar.net, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at elbashayer.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
- Seen at lomazoma.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 26 February 2022
Related
More about NATO
See all 1,403 fact-checks- Falseaccording to Deutsche Welle22 January 2026"The United States had never received anything from NATO, despite having paid for it."International politicsUnited States
- Falseaccording to FactCheck.org22 January 2026“We paid for, in my opinion, 100% of NATO because they weren’t paying their bills.”International politicsUnited States
- Falseaccording to Deutsche Welle22 January 2026"Until I came along," the US "was paying for virtually 100% of NATO," Trump said, adding, "We paid for, in my opinion, 100% of NATO."International politicsUnited States
More in International politics
See all 8,234 fact-checks- Falseaccording to FACTLY5 November 2026The video shows External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar recounting how a Russian minister mocked him over the India-China border dispute.International politicsVideoIndia
- Falseaccording to FACTLY4 November 2026Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov stated that India is neither a Russian ally nor a superpower and has no right to interfere in or advise Russia on its foreign policy decisions concerning Russia, Ukraine, the …International politicsRussia
- Misleadingaccording to Factcrescendo Sri Lanka12 October 2026The Indian Supreme Court has recently declared Katchatheevu to be Sri Lankan territory, as a result of President Anura Kumara Dissanayake's talks with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi.International politicsIndia
Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org
The verdict belongs to the newsroom: report an error in it to them, through their article above. Report an error in what Factiz added, such as the translation, the theme or the names, to us.
Record from: EUvsDisinfo, European External Action Service. Licence: EEAS legal notice: reuse is authorised, provided the source is acknowledged; snapshot: Mendeley Data yhdtkszvgp v3, CC BY 4.0.
The sources are the verdict.