Asymptomatic COVID-19 patients who supposedly aren't contagious? That's at least what Swiss blogger Jean-Dominique Michel claims, drawing that conclusion from a study conducted in Wuhan: no viable SARS-CoV-2 virus was found in cultures from asymptomatic positive cases, all close contacts of the asymptomatic positive cases tested negative, which indicates the asymptomatic positive cases detected in this study were unlikely to be infectious.
Machine-translated from French. Original: Des patients du COVID-19 sans symptômes qui ne seraient pas contagieux ? C'est en tout cas ce qu'affirme le blogueur suisse Jean-Dominique Michel qui tire une sorte de conclusion en se basant sur une étude réalisée à Wuhan : « Dans la présente étude, la culture du virus a été réalisée sur des échantillons de cas positifs asymptomatiques, et n'a trouvé aucun virus SRAS-CoV-2 viable. Tous les contacts étroits des cas positifs asymptomatiques se sont révélés négatifs, ce qui indique que les cas positifs asymptomatiques détectés dans cette étude étaient peu susceptibles d'être infectieux ».
Is it true?
Misleadingaccording to dpa
dpa checked this claim on 9 December 2020.
“L'étude est juste, mais l'interprétation qu'en fait la publication Facebook est fausse. Certains patients asymptomatiques peuvent être très contagieux.”
Français
Read the fact-check at dpa
Related
More about Wuhan
See all 152 fact-checks- Falseaccording to 日本ファクトチェックセンター10 February 2025Did the White House officially confirm that the new coronavirus originated from a lab in Wuhan?Machine-translated from Japanese. Original: ホワイトハウスが新型コロナウイルスの起源を武漢の研究所と正式認定?HealthUnited States
- Checkedby dpa25 October 2024The Wuhan biolab belongs to the pharmaceutical company GlaxoSmithKline, and other claims.Machine-translated from German. Original: Das Biolabor in Wuhan gehört dem Pharmaunternehmen GlaxoSmithKline und weitere Behauptungen.HealthChina mainland
- Trueaccording to Lupa20 March 2024This vaccine [given to children in Brazil] is made with the original Wuhan 2019 strain.Machine-translated from Portuguese. Original: “Essa vacina [aplicada em crianças no Brasil] é feita com a cepa original de Wuhan 2019”HealthBrazil
More in Health
See all 16,647 fact-checks- Trueaccording to فکتنامه17 November 2026More than 14 percent of people in Iran have diabetes, and about 25 percent are at risk of developing it.Machine-translated from Persian. Original: بیش از ۱۴ درصد مردم ایران مبتلا و حدود ۲۵ درصد در معرض ابتلا به دیابت هستند.HealthIran
- Falseaccording to Factcrescendo Sri Lanka16 November 2026Video shows a premature baby placed on his older sister's chest by doctors after their mother died in childbirth.HealthVideo
- Checkedby Factcrescendo Sri Lanka16 November 2026A video of a medical team calming a premature baby by placing it on its older sister's chest, because the mother died during childbirthMachine-translated from Tamil. Original: பிரசவத்தின் போது தாய் இறந்துவிட்டதால், குறைமாதக் குழந்தையை அக்காவின் மார்பில் வைத்து மருத்துவக் குழுவினர் அமைதிப்படுத்தும் காணொளிHealthVideo
NamesWuhan
Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org
The verdict belongs to the newsroom: report an error in it to them, through their article above. Report an error in what Factiz added, such as the translation, the theme or the names, to us.
Record from: Data Commons (ClaimReview feed), with the fact-check of the newsroom named. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Factiz added the language, the verdict category and the grouping of the same claim.
The sources are the verdict.