Months after a court case in Canada ended, the claim keeps circulating online that US climate scientist Michael E. Mann lost a lawsuit. The 'hockey stick graph' he developed, which depicts the current global warming, supposedly got exposed as a fake: 'Court ruling knocks the CO2 pope off his throne,' it says. Or also: 'Embarrassing setback for well-known climate scientist.' And even: 'Court exposes the lie about man-made climate change.'
Machine-translated from German. Original: Monate nach dem Ende eines Gerichtsverfahrens in Kanada macht im Netz noch immer die Behauptung die Runde, US-Klimaforscher Michael E. Mann habe einen Prozess verloren. Die von Mann entwickelte "Hockeyschläger-Kurve", die die gegenwärtige globale Erwärmung beschreibt, sei als Fälschung entlarvt: "Gerichtsurteil stürzt CO2-Papst vom Thron", heißt es. Oder auch: "Peinlicher Rückschlag für bekannten Klimaforscher". Und sogar: "Gericht entlarvt Lüge vom menschengemachten Klimawandel".
Is it true?
Falseaccording to Deutsche Presse-Agentur
Deutsche Presse-Agentur checked this claim on 3 February 2020.
“egenstand des Verfahrens war eine Verleumdungsklage, Manns wissenschaftliche Arbeit stand nicht zur Debatte. Das Gericht hat die Klage abgewiesen, ein Urteil gab es nicht.”
Related
More about Canada
See all 294 fact-checks- Checkedby Factcrescendo Sri Lanka19 November 2026That the proposed new uniform to be given to the Sri Lanka Police is similar to the Canadian police uniform, and that these are photographs of itMachine-translated from Sinhala. Original: ශ්රී ලංකා පොලීසියට ලබා දෙන යෝජිත නව නිල ඇඳුම කැනඩා පොලිස් නිල ඇඳුමට සමාන බවත්, එහි ඡායාරූප මෙය බවත්Crime and justiceImageSri Lanka
- Checkedby VérifRadar12 October 2026NYPD has more full-time uniformed personnel than Canada’s armyCrime and justiceUnited States
- Checkedby VérifRadar8 September 2026Trump says Canada is ripping off the United States with maple syrupMachine-translated from French. Original: Trump dit que le Canada arnaque les États-Unis avec le sirop d’érableInternational politicsUnited States
More in Climate, energy and nature
See all 3,105 fact-checks- FalseFactiz19 November 2026Spain: A farmer found a "climate changer" in one of his wheat fields.Machine-translated from Dutch. Original: Spanje: Een boer vond een "klimaatveranderaar" in een van zijn tarwevelden.Climate, energy and natureMissing or out of contextaccording to the newsroomVideoSpain
- FalseFactiz19 November 2026Norway is demolishing wind farms because deformed reindeer are being born because of the turbines.Machine-translated from Dutch. Original: Noorwegen breekt windparken af omdat er door de molens misvormde rendieren worden geboren.Climate, energy and natureMade upaccording to the newsroomNorway
- Falseaccording to فکتنامه13 November 2026Gas consumption in Iran and China is almost equal, and together with Qatar they rank first.Machine-translated from Persian. Original: مصرف گاز ایران و چین تقریبا برابر است و همراه با قطر در رتبه نخست قرار داردClimate, energy and nature
NamesCanada
Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org
The verdict belongs to the newsroom: report an error in it to them, through their article above. Report an error in what Factiz added, such as the translation, the theme or the names, to us.
Record from: Data Commons (ClaimReview feed), with the fact-check of the newsroom named. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Factiz added the language, the verdict category and the grouping of the same claim.
The sources are the verdict.