國際政治
30 years ago, US Secretary of State James Baker promised the whole world – if Mikhail Gorbachev agrees to unite Germany, NATO will not move one inch to the East.
這是真的嗎?
不實根據EUvsDisinfo
EUvsDisinfo 於 2019年12月1日 查核了這項查核內容。
“disinformation”
English
閱讀 EUvsDisinfo 的事實查核報告
根據 EUvsDisinfo,為什麼這是假的
- Mikhail Gorbachev, then-president of the Soviet Union, has himself confirmed that the promise was never made.
- Central and Eastern European countries began seeking NATO membership themselves in the early 1990s.
- NATO considers applications from candidate countries that want to join of their own national will, so enlargement is not directed against Russia.
內容為英文,與駁斥文章原文一致。
由 Factiz 根據 EUvsDisinfo 的駁斥內容整理而成(CC BY 4.0)。 閱讀駁斥內容
我們抽樣逐點人工檢查了 292 個要點,其中 3 個與來源不完全相符。 回報錯誤
這項查核內容的相關資訊
- 首次出現
- 2019年12月1日, baltnews.lt, 根據 EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force)
- 又稱
- “The United States has failed to uphold a promise that NATO would not expand into Eastern Europe, a deal made during the 1990 negotiations between the West and the Soviet Union over German unification: in February 1990 …”
- “There has been an agreement between president Bush and president Gorbachev that NATO won’t be enlarged by the Eastern European countries in exchange for USSR’s agreement with the unification of Germany.”
出現在哪裡
- 發現於 baltnews.lt, 根據 EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 2019年12月1日
也以這些形式出現
同一則訊息共被查核 22 次,語言包括 1 種語言。- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2016年6月5日The United States has failed to uphold a promise that NATO would not expand into Eastern Europe, a deal made during the 1990 negotiations between the West and the Soviet Union over German unification: in February 1990 …國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2017年2月10日There has been an agreement between president Bush and president Gorbachev that NATO won’t be enlarged by the Eastern European countries in exchange for USSR’s agreement with the unification of Germany.國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2019年4月3日At the time of German reunification, NATO promised Gorbachev that it would not expand to the East in the case the USSR gave up the Warsaw Pact and allowed the fall of Berlin wall.國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2019年4月4日In 1989 NATO promised Russia it would not expand after the Cold War. Mikhail Gorbachev knew: If East Germany joins NATO, the Eastern European countries could then follow this example. But the West assured him at the …國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2019年6月20日The USA promised Russia that there will be no NATO expansion to the East. US Secretary of State, James Baker, had agreed with Gorbachev in 1990 in his negotiations on German reunification that there would be no …國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2019年10月28日In 1990 the US government promised the then president of the Soviet Union, Mikhail Gorbachev, that the Atlantic Alliance would not expand to the East.國際政治美國英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2019年11月22日In 1990, the president of the Soviet Union, Mikhail Gorbachev, was assured by the US government that NATO would not expand to the East.國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2020年6月14日At the end of the 1980s, when Mikhail Gorbachev agreed to withdraw Soviet troops from Germany, American officials repeatedly promised Gorbachev that NATO would not expand eastward after the reunification of Germany.國際政治美國英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2020年6月28日The West promised Moscow in the course of the negotiations on German unification in 1990 that NATO will not expand eastwards. In the book, the Swiss historian Daniele Ganser also discusses NATO’s eastward expansion …國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2020年8月9日In the last three decades, NATO has continuously expanded eastward to Russia’s borders, despite former Secretary of State James Baker’s pledge to Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev that the West would not deploy troops …國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2020年11月15日Gorbachev was promised that NATO would not “go east”. Where is NATO now? In West Germany, there was NATO. East Germany was not a part of NATO. They promised in words, and then what?國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2021年3月8日Western countries promised Soviet President Gorbachev in 1990 not to expand NATO eastward but then ignored those promises.國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2021年5月25日The USA has broken twelve times its promise made in 1990, in the course of the annexation of the GDR to the FRG [...], not to expand NATO eastwards beyond the borders of Germany. This is attested to by both the former …國際政治美國英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2021年9月5日What has not been put on paper, history quickly reduces to zero - just like the promise made by then-German Chancellor Helmut Kohl and then-British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher to then-Soviet President Mikhail …國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2021年11月6日First, if Russia wasn’t going to come to it, NATO decided to come to Russia, engaging in a protracted policy of expansion which brought the alliance’s borders right up against Russia in pointed violations of assurances …國際政治俄羅斯英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2021年12月6日In 1990 former US Secretary of State James Baker promised the Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev that NATO would not expand eastwards beyond reunified Germany.國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2022年1月11日There is a record of [James] Baker talking to the Soviet leadership, and there is plenty of other evidence to suggest that NATO has promised that they will not even leave West German territory after German reunification.國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2022年1月16日At the time of Germany's reunification, the US promised Gorbachev that NATO would not expand eastwards.國際政治英文
- 不實根據Washington Post2024年5月8日“When the wall came down in the Soviet Union and Europe, [Soviet President Mikhail] Gorbachev destroyed himself politically by doing something that was very, very courageous. He went to [President George H.W.] Bush. He …國際政治英文
相關內容
所屬專題北約東擴是戰爭起因的說法
更多關於 James Baker 的內容
查看全部 10 份事實查核報告 項- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2022年1月15日NATO twice made a promise to Russia that it would not expand eastward. In 1990, during the negotiations over the unification of West and East Germany, and then, again, in 1993, when NATO was extending its Partnership …國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2022年1月11日There is a record of [James] Baker talking to the Soviet leadership, and there is plenty of other evidence to suggest that NATO has promised that they will not even leave West German territory after German reunification.國際政治英文
- 不實根據EUvsDisinfo2022年1月8日A number of long-secret documents reveal that Moscow has been promised that the military bloc will not accept any more states. Not just documents, but a series of Western leaders at the time, including Secretary of …國際政治俄羅斯英文
國際政治 的更多內容
查看全部 8,238 份事實查核報告 項- 不實Factiz2026年11月19日這個政治謊言 v Van der Leyen:俄羅斯被她指責切斷了天然氣,但那其實是歐盟自己幹的。由荷蘭文機器翻譯而來。原文: Deze politieke leugen v Van der Leyen: Rusland krijgt van haar de schuld van afsluiting van het gas, maar dat deed de EU toch echt zelf.國際政治缺少背景或脫離脈絡依查核機構所述
- 不實Factiz2026年11月19日歐盟自2022年起為能源向俄羅斯支付了3020億歐元,遠比官方數字所說的多。由荷蘭文機器翻譯而來。原文: De EU betaalde Rusland sinds 2022 voor 302 miljard euro aan energie, veel meer dan de officiële cijfers zeggen.國際政治缺少背景或脫離脈絡依查核機構所述
- 誤導Factiz2026年11月19日NATO本應遵守協議,不再讓更多國家朝俄羅斯方向加入成為成員。所以俄羅斯在烏克蘭劃下了紅線。由荷蘭文機器翻譯而來。原文: De NATO had zich aan de afspraak moeten houden en niet meer landen richting Rusland lid moeten maken. Dus de rode lijn heeft Rusland bij …戰爭與衝突缺少背景或脫離脈絡依查核機構所述
這裡有錯誤嗎? 用電子郵件回報info@factiz.org
查核結果由查核機構負責:若要回報查核結果的錯誤,請透過上方他們的文章聯絡他們。若是 Factiz 自己加上的內容有錯,例如翻譯、主題或名稱,請回報給我們。
紀錄來源:EUvsDisinfo, European External Action Service。授權:EEAS legal notice: reuse is authorised, provided the source is acknowledged; snapshot: Mendeley Data yhdtkszvgp v3, CC BY 4.0。
來源就是查核結果。