The German state took in 799.3 billion euros in taxes in 2019 - but where exactly does this money actually come from? The headline of an article claims: "Of 82 million inhabitants, only 15 million are still effective net taxpayers" (archived here). The intention is to convey that the remaining people in work make no contribution to tax revenue without receiving anything in return. The following calculation is offered: Only 27 million of the people in work in Germany are "net taxpayers". Of these, "12 million depend directly or indirectly on the state", so they have to be subtracted: "Because their wages are paid from tax money, and so are the wage taxes and other taxes." Therefore, in the end, there are only 15 million people in work in Germany "who effectively pay taxes under their own power".
Machine-translated from German. Original: 799,3 Milliarden Euro Steuern hat der deutsche Staat im Jahr 2019 eingenommen - aber woher kommt dieses Geld eigentlich genau? In der Überschrift eines Artikels wird behauptet: «Von 82 Millionen Einwohnern sind bloß noch 15 Mio effektive Netto-Steuerzahler» (hier archiviert). Zum Ausdruck gebracht werden soll, dass die restlichen Erwerbstätigen keinen Beitrag zu den Steuereinnahmen leisten würden, ohne dafür eine Gegenleistung zu erhalten. Dazu angestellt wird folgende Rechnung: Nur 27 Millionen der Erwerbstätigen in Deutschland seien «Nettosteuerzahler». Davon würden «12 Millionen direkt oder indirekt vom Staat abhängen», sie müssten darum rausgerechnet werden: «Denn ihre Löhne werden von Steuergeldern bezahlt und somit auch die Lohnsteuern und anderen Steuern». Deswegen seien es schlussendlich nur 15 Millionen Erwerbstätige in Deutschland, «die effektiv Steuern aus eigener Kraft zahlen».
Is it true?
Misleadingaccording to dpa
dpa checked this claim on 15 October 2020.
“Die Aussagen zu Nettosteuerzahlern sind stark vereinfacht und nicht in den Kontext gestellt.”
Deutsch
Read the fact-check at dpa
Related
More about Germany
See all 1,202 fact-checks- Misleadingaccording to BR24 Faktenfuchs20 November 2026Norway has stopped its "electricity aid" for Germany, and France will soon do the same.Machine-translated from German. Original: Norwegen hat "Strom-Hilfe" für Deutschland eingestellt und Frankreich wird das auch bald tun.Economy and moneyGermany
- Falseaccording to فکتنامه28 September 2026Mojtaba Khamenei has bought a factory called "Germen Machine" in Germany.Machine-translated from Persian. Original: مجتبی خامنهای کارخانهای به نام «ژرمن ماشین» را در آلمان خریدهاستEconomy and moneyIran
- Falseaccording to Deutsche Welle3 August 2026A candidate from the Die Linke party is suspected of organizing underground sex parties for members of the LGBTQ+ community at a German universityElectionsGermany
More in Economy and money
See all 8,334 fact-checks- Checkedby Factcrescendo Sri Lanka20 November 2026That the price of a bottle of arrack (750 ml extra special arrack) has been reduced by 530 rupees, and that alcohol prices went down with the 2027 budgetMachine-translated from Sinhala. Original: ගල් අරක්කු (මිලි ලීටර් 750 අති විශේෂ අරක්කු) බෝතලයක මිල රුපියල් 530කින් අඩු කර ඇති බවත්, 2027 අයවැයෙන් මත්පැන් මිල පහළ ගිය බවත්Economy and moneySri Lanka
- Checkedby VérifRadar20 November 2026Minister of Finance François-Philippe Champagne paid his partner, Anne-Marie Gaudet, a $2 million dollar bonus for the Alto high speed rail projectPolitics and governmentCanada
- Checkedby فکتنامه20 November 2026How large is Iran's gas shortfall in the winter of 1405?Machine-translated from Persian. Original: کسری گاز ایران در زمستان ۱۴۰۵ چقدر است؟Economy and moneyIran
NamesGermany
Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org
The verdict belongs to the newsroom: report an error in it to them, through their article above. Report an error in what Factiz added, such as the translation, the theme or the names, to us.
Record from: Data Commons (ClaimReview feed), with the fact-check of the newsroom named. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Factiz added the language, the verdict category and the grouping of the same claim.
The sources are the verdict.