For a long time, a social media post in several versions has been circulating that accuses ARD's weather forecast of manipulation by comparing its graphics: a 2009 map supposedly showed regions above 30 degrees in green, while a 2019 map showed temperatures below 30 degrees on a red background, suggesting that ARD manipulates viewers through colour to portray climate change as more dramatic than it supposedly is.
Machine-translated from German. Original: In den sozialen Medien kursiert seit langem ein Post in verschiedenen Varianten, welcher der ARD-Wettervorhersage Manipulation unterstellt. Dabei werden Grafiken des ARD-Wetterberichts miteinander verglichen. Demnach hat der TV-Sender auf einer Karte von 2009 Regionen mit Temperaturen von mehr als 30 Grad in Grün dargestellt, in der Karte von 2019 hingegen Temperaturen von weniger als 30 Grad auf rotem Grund. Damit wird suggeriert, die ARD manipuliere über die Farbgebung die Fernsehzuschauer und stelle den Klimawandel dramatischer dar, als er angeblich sei.
Is it true?
Misleadingaccording to Deutsche Presse-Agentur
Deutsche Presse-Agentur checked this claim on 23 July 2019.
“Die beiden Karten zeigen zwei vollkommen unterschiedliche Sachverhalte. Sie sind deshalb nicht vergleichbar. Auf reinen Temperatur-Karten unterlegte die ARD schon 1999 Temperaturen von weniger als 30 Grad mit roter Farbe.”
Related
More about ARD
See all 9 fact-checks- Falseaccording to Belarusian Investigative Center24 August 2023The head of the German TV channel ARD insulted viewers.Machine-translated from Russian. Original: Руководитель немецкого телеканала ARD оскорбил зрителейFamous people, sport and mediaGermany
- Misleadingaccording to dpa4 May 2023An ARD broadcast about global warming and the IPCC climate panel was banned.Machine-translated from German. Original: Eine ARD-Sendung über Erderwärmung und den Weltklimarat IPCC wurde verboten.Climate, energy and natureGermany
- Falseaccording to dpa18 May 2021ARD is manipulating its election poll and leaving the Freie Wähler result out of the picture.Machine-translated from German. Original: Die ARD manipuliert und lässt in Wahlumfrage das Ergebnis der Freien Wähler unter den Tisch fallen.ElectionsImageGermany
More in Climate, energy and nature
See all 3,103 fact-checks- Falseaccording to فکتنامه13 November 2026Gas consumption in Iran and China is almost equal, and together with Qatar they rank first.Machine-translated from Persian. Original: مصرف گاز ایران و چین تقریبا برابر است و همراه با قطر در رتبه نخست قرار داردClimate, energy and nature
- Misleadingaccording to Vera Files12 November 2026DENR is selling 144,000 hectares of forest land in the Davao Region to private investors.Climate, energy and naturePhilippines
- Misleadingaccording to FactCheck.org6 November 2026“Half of the states have renewable portfolio [standards], half of them don’t. Forty-five percent more expensive electricity in the states that have them. That’s not coincidence.”Climate, energy and natureUnited States
NamesARD
Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org
The verdict belongs to the newsroom: report an error in it to them, through their article above. Report an error in what Factiz added, such as the translation, the theme or the names, to us.
Record from: Data Commons (ClaimReview feed), with the fact-check of the newsroom named. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Factiz added the language, the verdict category and the grouping of the same claim.
The sources are the verdict.