Skip to content
Crime and justice

All the appointments [in the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR)], especially the French judges, are politically made appointments for patronage, to keep a sense of political balance between the right and left parties. It is a kind of benefits for every member, so there is no legal value for these judges. In general, they are people who reached their seat during an unopposed selection, and this is normal. But because the issue is political [regarding the case of Alexei Navalny], the judges are vulnerable and open to any political pressure that comes from their countries. In other words, these judges don’t make their decision independently, they are in constant contact with the countries that nominate them and then appoint them. This is why there is no real legal value for their call [to an “immediate” release of Navalny].

Is it true?

Falseaccording to EUvsDisinfo

EUvsDisinfo checked this claim on 19 February 2021.

“disinformation”

  1. English

    Read the fact-check at EUvsDisinfo

Why it is false, according to EUvsDisinfo

  • ECHR judges hear cases as individuals, do not represent the state they were elected in respect of, and cannot engage in activities incompatible with independence and impartiality.
  • ECHR decisions are binding for Russia because it ratified the European Convention on Human Rights in 1998.

Summarised by Factiz from the EUvsDisinfo disproof (CC BY 4.0). Read the disproof

In a sample, we checked 292 points by hand; 3 did not fully match the source. Report an error

Around this claim

First seen
19 February 2021, RT Arabic - YouTube, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force) · and 1 more

Where it turned up

  • Seen at RT Arabic - YouTube, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 19 February 2021
  • Seen at arabic.rt.com, according to EUvsDisinfo (EEAS East StratCom Task Force), 19 February 2021

Related

NamesEuropean Court of Human RightsAlexei Navalny

Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org

The verdict belongs to the newsroom: report an error in it to them, through their article above. Report an error in what Factiz added, such as the translation, the theme or the names, to us.

Record from: EUvsDisinfo, European External Action Service. Licence: EEAS legal notice: reuse is authorised, provided the source is acknowledged; snapshot: Mendeley Data yhdtkszvgp v3, CC BY 4.0.

The sources are the verdict.