"Unconstitutional" - that is how the Federal Constitutional Court ruled on 25 July 2012 on the Federal Election Law reformed in 2011, and a blogger from the "DERUWA" blog (Deutschland-Russland-Wahrheit) draws a sweeping conclusion: according to that ruling, there has been "not a single valid election" from 1956 until today, so all laws and ordinances formulated since then are "null", and the decision-making bodies, the Bundesrat and the Bundestag, were not lawful or legitimate at all, so the rule of law has been "extinct" for more than half a century.
Machine-translated from German. Original: «Verfassungswidrig» – dieses Urteil fällte das Bundesverfassungsgericht am 25. Juli 2012 über das 2011 reformierte Bundeswahlgesetz. Ein Autor des Blogs «DERUWA» (Deutschland-Russland-Wahrheit) zieht daraus einen weitreichenden Schluss: Dem Urteil folgend habe es von 1956 an bis heute «keine einzige gültige Wahl» gegeben, womit auch alle seither formulierten Gesetze und Verordnungen «nichtig» seien; die Beschlussgremien, Bundesrat und Bundestag, seien schließlich gar nicht rechtmäßig und legitimiert gewesen. Der Rechtsstaat sei darum seit mehr als einem halben Jahrhundert «erloschen» (hier archiviert).
Is it true?
Falseaccording to dpa
dpa checked this claim on 1 October 2020.
“Die Behauptung ist falsch. Das Urteil des Verfassungsgerichts aus dem Jahr 2012 bezog sich allein auf die seinerzeit jüngste und noch nicht angewandte Fassung des Bundeswahlgesetzes – und erklärte damit nicht alle vorangehenden Wahlen für nichtig.”
Deutsch
Read the fact-check at dpa
Related
More about German Bundestag
See all 45 fact-checks- Falseaccording to dpa8 August 2024The photo shows a sign at the underground parking garage entrance of the Bundestag.Machine-translated from German. Original: Das Foto zeigt ein Schild an der Tiefgarageneinfahrt des Bundestags.Politics and governmentImageGermany
- Falseaccording to dpa4 July 2024The Bundestag administration has announced that the 2025 Bundestag elections will be cancelled in the event of war.Machine-translated from German. Original: Die Bundestagsverwaltung hat angekündigt, dass die Bundestagswahlen 2025 im Kriegsfall ausfallen.ElectionsGermany
- Partly trueaccording to Du-Check24 May 2024Right side of history? A 'pro-pedophile' activist group is celebrating because Germany decriminalized possession of child pornography. According to the Bundestag, the bill stipulates that 'possession and acquisition …Machine-translated from Croatian. Original: “Prava strana povijesti? „Pro-pedofilska“ aktivistička skupina slavi jer je Njemačka dekriminalizirala posjedovanje dječje pornografije …Crime and justiceGermany
More in Elections
See all 7,784 fact-checks- Trueaccording to maharat-news18 November 2026Have by-elections in West Bekaa become mandatory after the extension of the Parliament's term?Machine-translated from Arabic. Original: هل أصبح إجراء الانتخابات الفرعية في البقاع الغربي إلزاميًا بعد تمديد ولاية مجلس النواب؟ElectionsLebanon
- Checkedby Factcrescendo Sri Lanka17 November 2026A video showing the only white person among black people at a Democratic Party election rally in the state of MichiganMachine-translated from Sinhala. Original: මිචිගන් ප්රාන්තයේ ඩිමොක්රටික් පක්ෂයේ මැතිවරණ රැලියක කලු ජාතිකයින් මැද සිටි එකම සුදු ජාතිකයා දැක්වෙන වීඩියෝවක්ElectionsVideoUnited States
- Checkedby Factcrescendo Sri Lanka13 November 2026A video of people around the world enthusiastically celebrating the defeat of Trump's Republican Party in the US midterm elections.Machine-translated from Tamil. Original: அமெரிக்க இடைத்தேர்தலில் ட்ரம்பின் குடியரசுக் கட்சி தோல்வியடைந்ததை உலக மக்கள் உற்சாகமாகக் கொண்டாடும் காணொளி.ElectionsVideoUnited States
NamesGerman Bundestag
Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org
The verdict belongs to the newsroom: report an error in it to them, through their article above. Report an error in what Factiz added, such as the translation, the theme or the names, to us.
Record from: Data Commons (ClaimReview feed), with the fact-check of the newsroom named. Licence: CC BY 4.0. Factiz added the language, the verdict category and the grouping of the same claim.
The sources are the verdict.