Skip to content

Machine translation from Dutch. Read the original

Factiz Radar19 November 2026 · Checked with AI, reviewed by the editors

Norwegian wind farms Storheia and Roan are not being demolished, and deformed reindeer played no role

What circulates on X

“Norway is demolishing wind farms because deformed reindeer are being born because of the turbines.”

Is it true?

Falseaccording to Factiz

In 2021 the court ruled on the grazing land of Sámi reindeer herders, not on deformities, and after two agreements the 151 turbines keep turning123.

Since 11 August 2026 · 1 post · 101,303 views on 18 November

Since 11 August a post has been circulating on X claiming that Norway is demolishing two wind farms because deformed reindeer are being born9. In 2021 the Supreme Court of Norway declared the permits for Storheia and Roan invalid because the Sámi reindeer herders had lost their winter pastures, not because of the health of the animals1. After agreements in December 2023 and March 2024, the 151 turbines keep turning23.

Screenshot of a post on X about Norwegian wind farms and deformed reindeer, with a link card from a German trade magazine. Stamp: FALSE.
What circulates. Post on X, 11 August 2026, 20:15, with a link to agrarheute from 2021.

What we know

The post on X names two wind farms with a combined 151 turbines, Storheia and Roan, on the Fosen peninsula in central Norway9. These farms exist: Storheia has 80 turbines and Roan 71, and both opened in 20194. The post contains a link to a German trade magazine from October 2021, which reported at the time that the 151 turbines had to go59.

The court case was real. On 11 October 2021, the Supreme Court of Norway ruled unanimously that the permits for both farms were invalid1. The farms violated the right of the Sámi reindeer herders of Fosen to enjoy their own culture, which is laid down in Article 27 of the UN Covenant on Civil and Political Rights1. The core of the ruling was that the reindeer had in practice lost the winter pastures near the farms, and that this threatened reindeer herding on Fosen1.

The judgment says nothing about the health of reindeer, and nothing about deformed calves either1. The court also did not say what should happen to the turbines4.

They were not demolished. In December 2023, the reindeer herders of Sør-Fosen reached an agreement on Storheia, with extra land, compensation and a veto on new wind energy after the permit expires2. The Norwegian national human rights institution wrote that this agreement appears to remedy the violation2. On 6 March 2024 an agreement followed for Roan: 7 million kroner per year until the permit expires in 2043, and after that a new permit only if the reindeer herders consent3. Electricity continues to be generated as before3.

The deformed reindeer come from a letter to the editor in the Landshuter Zeitung, a Bavarian newspaper, dated 9 October 202367. The letter attributed the deformities to vibrations from the turbines, and then circulated on Facebook and X6. AFP asked six reindeer researchers in Norway, Sweden and Austria about it, and none of them knew of a study showing deformities or miscarriages caused by wind turbines6. Research does show that reindeer avoid areas around turbines, especially during calving season6.

The story is therefore not new. At the beginning of 2024, EDMO, the European network of fact-checkers, reported that it was also circulating in a Dutch translation11.

What we do not know

We do not know who first translated the 2023 letter into Dutch, or whether the August post goes back to it. We did not read the letter itself; what it said, we know from the checks by AFP and Mimikama. We could not open the Norwegian government's press releases about the agreements. That the turbines are still running now, we infer from Aneo, Store norske leksikon and Euronews; we saw no production figures from after September 2026.

Still to find out

  • The Norwegian government's press releases about the two agreements, and the date of the agreement for Storheia. We could not open them.
  • Whether a Dutch-language check already existed in 2023 or 2024, at Nieuwscheckers, Factcheck Vlaanderen or Knack.
  • We could not open the check by AFP Factcheck Nederland of 24 August, and we read the one by AFP Faktencheck via GADMO.
  • The court case is real, the demolition and the deformed reindeer are not. We chose false; misleading can also be defended.

Contribute to this fact-check

For us a fact-check is the start of a conversation. Do you know more about one of these points, do you have a source we missed, or do you see a mistake? Email the editors and mention this check.

Email the editorsinfo@factiz.org

Timeline

  1. 11 October 2021The Supreme Court of Norway declares the permits for Storheia and Roan invalid.
  2. 18 October 2021Agrarheute writes that the 151 turbines have to go.
  3. 9 October 2023A letter to the editor in the Landshuter Zeitung about deformed reindeer calves.
  4. 13 December 2023AFP Faktencheck: there is no evidence of deformities caused by wind turbines.
  5. 16 December 2023Mimikama reaches the same conclusion.
  6. 19 December 2023The Norwegian national human rights institution reports the agreement for Storheia.
  7. 6 March 2024Agreement for Roan; the turbines keep turning.
  8. 11 August 202620:15The post about demolition and deformed reindeer on X.
  9. 24 August 2026AFP Factcheck Nederland checks the post.
  10. 14 September 2026Euronews: deformed reindeer caused by wind turbines have not been described anywhere.

Sources

11
  1. 1Høyesterett, het Hooggerechtshof van Noorwegen, HR-2021-1975-S, Statnett SF v. Sør-Fosen sijte e.a., 11 October 2021. domstol.no · archived copy (primary source)
  2. 2Norges nasjonale institusjon for menneskerettigheter (NIM), Agreement Reached with Reindeer Owners in Fosen (updated), 19 December 2023. nhri.no · archived copy (primary source)
  3. 3Aneo, mede-eigenaar van Roan Vind, Agreement on amicable settlement in Nord-Fosen, 6 March 2024. aneo.com · archived copy (primary source)
  4. 4Store norske leksikon, Fosen Vind, 5 August 2026. snl.no · archived copy (primary source)
  5. 5agrarheute, Rentiere statt Windkraft: 151 Windräder müssen weg, 18 October 2021. agrarheute.com · archived copy (news)
  6. 6AFP Faktencheck, via GADMO, Rentiere erleiden keine Fehlbildungen durch Windräder, 13 December 2023. gadmo.eu · archived copy (fact-check)
  7. 7Mimikama, Faktencheck: Keine Fehlbildungen bei Rentieren durch Windräder, 16 December 2023. mimikama.org · archived copy (fact-check)
  8. 8AFP Factcheck Nederland, Factcheck over de windparken en de rendieren in Noorwegen, 24 August 2026. factchecknederland.afp.com · archived copy (fact-check)
  9. 9X, De post over afbraak en misvormde rendieren, 11 August 2026. archived copy (primary source)
  10. 10Euronews, Wind turbines cause animal malformations: true or false?, 14 September 2026. euronews.com · archived copy (fact-check)
  11. 11EDMO, Wind turbines and poisoned animals: a 'New Denial''s popular disinformation narrative against renewable energy, 25 January 2024. edmo.eu · archived copy (fact-check)

Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org

Written by Claude (AI)Reviewed by the Factiz editorsPublished on 19 November 2026