Machine translation from Dutch. Read the original
No treaty or signed agreement barred NATO from admitting countries toward Russia
What circulates on X
“De NATO had zich aan de afspraak moeten houden en niet meer landen richting Rusland lid moeten maken. Dus de rode lijn heeft Rusland bij Oekraïne getrokken.”
Is it true?
Misleadingaccording to Factiz
Western politicians said orally in 1990 that NATO would not move eastward, but on paper only something about East Germany appeared, and in 1997 Russia itself signed up to every country's right to choose124.
Since 19 October 2026 · 1 post · 1,070 likes and 853 replies on 18 November
A Dutch post on X says NATO broke an agreement by admitting countries toward Russia11. In 1990, American and German politicians told Mikhail Gorbachev orally that NATO would not move eastward, but the treaty on the reunification of Germany only says something about the east of Germany12. In 1997, Russia itself signed an act with NATO that recognizes every country's right to choose how it arranges its security4.

What we know
On Saturday 17 October 2026 at 19:48, a post appeared on X, addressed to everyone who says Russia started the war for no reason11. According to the post, NATO should have kept to an agreement and not admitted countries toward Russia11. Which agreement is not stated11. The post does include a scan of the American record of the conversation between James Baker and Mikhail Gorbachev of 9 February 1990, from the National Security Archive, with the sentence about "one inch to the east"111. Above the scan it says that the conversation was about a united Germany in NATO and "no NATO expansion"11. In the record itself, the sentence appears within a condition: if the United States remains present in a Germany that belongs to NATO111.
What was said in 1990
On 9 February 1990, the American Secretary of State James Baker spoke in Moscow with Gorbachev about the reunification of Germany1. According to the American record, he said three times that NATO would move "not one inch" to the east, if a united Germany remained a member of NATO1. A day later, Chancellor Helmut Kohl told Gorbachev that NATO should not expand its area of operation1. The West German minister Hans-Dietrich Genscher had already said so in a speech at the end of January1.
It was not only about East Germany, writes the National Security Archive of George Washington University, which published the records in 20171. For example, in March 1991 the British minister Douglas Hurd still said that NATO had no plans to admit countries from Central and Eastern Europe1. But President George Bush told Kohl at the end of February 1990 that the West had won and Moscow had not1.
What made it onto paper
The treaty on reunification was signed in Moscow on 12 September 1990 by both Germanys, the Soviet Union, the United States, the United Kingdom and France2. No foreign troops and nuclear weapons may be stationed in the east of Germany, and Germany may itself choose which alliance it belongs to2. It says nothing about other countries or about NATO expansion2. According to the National Security Archive, the assurances about the east are not in treaties, only in records of conversations1.
In 1997, NATO and Russia signed an act on their relations in Paris4. In it, they recognize every country's right to choose for itself how it arranges its security4. On new members, the act only says that NATO has no plan to station nuclear weapons there4. In 2008, the NATO countries agreed that Ukraine and Georgia will become members6. Ukraine is not a member now9.
What Gorbachev himself said
In an interview in 2014, Gorbachev said that NATO expansion was not discussed at all in 19903. According to him, Baker's assurance was about East Germany, and that arrangement is being respected3. He did call the later decision to expand NATO contrary to the spirit of what had been assured to him in 19903.
The story now
The Russian president Vladimir Putin said in December 2025 that no expansion to the east had been promised publicly7. On 26 July 2026 he said that the West had promised Gorbachev not to expand NATO8. NATO calls the promise a myth: the idea from 1990 was dropped, and no treaty with Russia forbids new members5. At talks in Abu Dhabi in November 2026, Russia asked for a ban on further expansion, according to leaked documents9.
Whether NATO's expansion provoked the war is a debate among researchers, and we do not decide it here. The post says something else: that there was an agreement11. That was never signed12. There were oral assurances in 1990 and 1991, in conversations about Germany1. In 2022, PolitiFact rated a similar claim mostly false10. In Dutch, dpa arrived at taken out of context in 2025, and Nieuwscheckers at partly false1213.
What we do not know
We do not know which agreement the writer means; the record of 9 February 1990 that comes with the post is a conversation, not an agreement on paper. Whether the assurances of 1990 were a political promise is read differently: the National Security Archive calls the later Russian complaints grounded in the records of the time, NATO calls the promise a myth15.
Still to find out
- Other fact-checkers chose differently. When a claim mentioned a treaty or a signed agreement, AAP FactCheck, Polygraph and Lead Stories chose false; when it concerned a broken promise in general, PolitiFact, dpa and Nieuwscheckers chose a verdict in the middle. This post says 'the agreement', and we chose misleading.
Contribute to this fact-check
For us a fact-check is the start of a conversation. Do you know more about one of these points, do you have a source we missed, or do you see a mistake? Email the editors and mention this check.
Email the editorsinfo@factiz.org
Timeline
- 9 February 1990Baker tells Gorbachev in Moscow that NATO will move 'not one inch' to the east.
- 12 September 1990The treaty on the reunification of Germany is signed; it is only about Germany.
- 26 March 1991The British minister Hurd says NATO has no plans to admit countries from Central and Eastern Europe.
- 27 May 1997NATO and Russia sign their act in Paris, with every country's right to choose its security.
- 16 October 2014Gorbachev says NATO expansion was not discussed in 1990.
- 12 December 2017The National Security Archive publishes the records of the conversations of 1990 and 1991.
- 26 July 2026Putin says in Saint Petersburg that the West promised Gorbachev not to expand NATO.
- 17 October 202619:48The post on X about the broken agreement.
- 10 November 2026Russia asks in Abu Dhabi, according to leaked documents, for a ban on further NATO expansion.
Sources
13- 1National Security Archive (George Washington University), NATO Expansion: What Gorbachev Heard from Western Leaders Early On, 12 December 2017. nsarchive.gwu.edu · archived copy (primary source)
- 2German History in Documents and Images, Treaty on the Final Settlement with Respect to Germany (Twee-plus-Vierverdrag), 12 September 1990. germanhistorydocs.org · archived copy (primary source)
- 3Russia Beyond, Mikhail Gorbachev: I am against all walls, 16 October 2014. rbth.com · archived copy (news)
- 4NAVO, Founding Act on Mutual Relations, Cooperation and Security between NATO and the Russian Federation, 27 May 1997. nato.int · archived copy (primary source)
- 5NAVO, Setting the record straight, 11 November 2025. nato.int · archived copy (primary source)
- 6NAVO, Bucharest Summit Declaration, 3 April 2008. nato.int · archived copy (primary source)
- 7TASS, Russia insists on fulfillment of NATO's promises not to expand NATO eastwards, Putin, 4 December 2025. tass.com · archived copy (news)
- 8Interfax, Poetin: de NAVO beloofde Gorbatsjov niet uit te breiden (Dag van de Marine, Sint-Petersburg), 26 July 2026. interfax.ru · archived copy (news)
- 9Al Jazeera, 'NATO will collapse': Russia stalls Ukraine talks, seeks to divide Europe, 16 November 2026. aljazeera.com · archived copy (news)
- 10PolitiFact, Fact-checking claims that NATO, US broke agreement (oordeel: Mostly False), 28 February 2022. politifact.com · archived copy (fact-check)
- 11X, De post met de bewering, 17 October 2026. archived copy (primary source)
- 12dpa-factchecking, Harde beloften over oostgrens NAVO nooit op papier gezet (oordeel: uit context getrokken), 6 March 2025. dpa-factchecking.com · archived copy (fact-check)
- 13Nieuwscheckers, 'Geen centimeter oostwaarts': Hoe een mondelinge toezegging een oorlogsreden werd voor Poetin (oordeel: deels onwaar), 26 June 2025. nieuwscheckers.nl · archived copy (fact-check)
Related
More about NATO
See all 1,404 fact-checks- Falseaccording to Deutsche Welle22 January 2026"The United States had never received anything from NATO, despite having paid for it."International politicsUnited States
- Falseaccording to FactCheck.org22 January 2026“We paid for, in my opinion, 100% of NATO because they weren’t paying their bills.”International politicsUnited States
- Falseaccording to Deutsche Welle22 January 2026"Until I came along," the US "was paying for virtually 100% of NATO," Trump said, adding, "We paid for, in my opinion, 100% of NATO."International politicsUnited States
More in War and conflict
See all 14,672 fact-checks- Misleadingaccording to Factcrescendo Sri Lanka19 November 2026Gajendrakumar Ponnambalam demanded in Geneva that Sri Lanka be named an Eelam state and referred for war crimes.War and conflictSri Lanka
- FalseFactiz19 November 2026Remember the face of this 14-year-old who was pulled out of an Azov torture chamber near Kiev.Machine-translated from Dutch. Original: Onthoud het gezicht van deze 14-jarige die uit een martelkamer van Azov nabij Kiev werd gehaald.War and conflictMissing or out of contextaccording to the newsroomVideoUkraine
- FalseFactiz19 November 2026Ukraine bombed the Donbas from 2014 on and killed thousands of civilians there; now Zelensky wants the world to destroy Russia.Machine-translated from Dutch. Original: Oekraïne bombardeerde sinds 2014 de Donbas en doodde er duizenden burgers; nu wil Zelensky dat de wereld Rusland vernietigt.War and conflictMissing or out of contextaccording to the newsroomUkraine
Something wrong here? Report it by emailinfo@factiz.org